How to choose hardwood, luxury vinyl or carpet
Most homes end up with more than one of these. Here's how they compare, room by room, so you walk into the showroom with a short list instead of a blank page.
Room by room
Living and dining rooms
Hardwood or luxury vinyl plank. Hardwood if you want real wood that can be refinished later; vinyl if you have pets, kids, or a slab foundation.
Kitchen
Luxury vinyl first, hardwood second. Vinyl shrugs off spills. Hardwood works too if spills get wiped up rather than left to sit.
Bathrooms and laundry
Luxury vinyl tile or plank. Of the three, it's the only one we'd put in a full bathroom.
Bedrooms
Carpet, most of the time. It's warmer, quieter, and softer on bare feet in the morning. Hardwood is the alternative if allergies are a concern.
Stairs
Carpet or hardwood treads. See our stair guide for the trade-offs.
Rentals and busy family rooms
Luxury vinyl plank with a thick wear layer. Easy to clean, and individual planks can be replaced.
How they compare
Feel underfoot
Carpet is the softest and warmest. Luxury vinyl is softer and warmer than tile but firmer than carpet. Hardwood is firm with a little give, and feels like wood because it is.
Water
Many luxury vinyl lines have a waterproof core. Hardwood tolerates a spill wiped up quickly, not standing water. Carpet and pad hold onto spills, so it suits dry rooms.
Scratches and dents
Vinyl resists scratches according to its wear layer. Hardwood scratches and dents, but can be sanded and refinished. Carpet doesn't scratch, but shows wear in walking paths.
Noise
Carpet is the quietest, especially upstairs. Hard floors carry footsteps; the right underlayment helps, and many condo buildings require one.
Refreshing it later
Hardwood can be sanded and refinished, often more than once. Vinyl and carpet are replaced rather than refinished, though damaged vinyl planks can be swapped out.
Over concrete
Luxury vinyl and engineered hardwood both go over a flat, dry slab. Solid hardwood usually doesn't. Carpet goes over concrete with the right pad.
Then come and touch them
Photos can't tell you how a floor feels underfoot or how a color looks in your light. Walk into the showroom Monday to Friday, 8am to 4pm, or book a free estimate and we'll bring samples to you.
Read more: hardwood · luxury vinyl · carpet · all guides
Estimates
Free in-home estimate
We bring samples to your home, measure the rooms and send a written quote. No prices or dates until we've seen the job. What happens on the visit.
- Call
- (925) 691-7101
- Book online
- Pick a time
- Hours
- Mon–Fri, 8am–4pm
- License
- C-15 #998206