Choosing carpet or hardwood treads for stairs
Stairs take more wear than any other floor in the house, and they're the floor most likely to cause a slip. Here's how carpet and hardwood treads compare, and what installing each involves.
How they compare
Grip
Carpet has the most grip, which matters for kids, older family members and pets. Hardwood treads are smoother; a runner adds grip while keeping wood showing at the sides.
Noise
Carpet is much quieter. Hardwood stairs carry footsteps through the house.
Wear
Stair carpet wears fastest on the nose of each step. Hardwood treads scratch, but they can be sanded and refinished.
Cleaning
Hardwood wipes clean and doesn't hold pet hair. Carpet needs vacuuming step by step.
The look
Hardwood stairs are the classic choice when the floor around them is hardwood. Carpet keeps a soft, continuous look with the bedrooms upstairs.
What a stair carpet job involves
Each step is measured, a firm stair pad is fitted, and the carpet is installed either waterfall style (running over each nose straight to the next tread) or wrapped tightly under each nose for a tailored look.
What a hardwood tread job involves
Old carpet, pad and tack strip come off first. On many stairs the treads underneath are construction-grade and were never meant to be seen, so they're capped with new hardwood treads. Each tread is measured and cut for its own step, then stained to match the floor.
The middle ground
A runner over hardwood treads keeps the wood showing at the sides and adds grip and quiet down the middle. It's a common choice when the floor around the stairs is hardwood but the household has small kids, older family members or dogs.
Read more: hardwood vs vinyl vs carpet · all guides
Estimates
Free in-home estimate
We bring samples to your home, measure the rooms and send a written quote. No prices or dates until we've seen the job. What happens on the visit.
- Call
- (925) 691-7101
- Book online
- Pick a time
- Hours
- Mon–Fri, 8am–4pm
- License
- C-15 #998206